Skip to main content

Do you need to have knowledge of the subject matter you are editing?

Having the knowledge of the subject matter definitely gives some advantage to an editor. However, that is just a superficial aid, because either way, the first requirement of editing is that that you have to read the text or content assuming yourself as end reader or a layman, who does not know anything about the subject he/she is reading. What matters is that the content should be grammatically correct, error free, coherent, well illustrated and consistent. As a reader-editor, you should not get stuck in between the text, while reading. In addition to the aforementioned factors, there are some other factors that prove that you need not to have the knowledge of subject matter you are editing.

Editing Tools

Syllabus, in-house editing manual, style sheet, editorial board/team, both manual/hard copy and online references, spelling checkers, subject-matter experts in your editorial team, the EPR [Editorial Proof Reading] team, which will help in resolving any and every formatting issue, and last but not the least, you knowledge and wisdom are some of the major tools that will help you in the most critical editing of the subject that you may have not read at all.

Author is Subject-Matter Expert

The upcoming authors want to establish themselves as good authors. Therefore, while preparing the manuscript, they do not leave any margin for error, or plagiarism; rather, they always cite the books or the names of the websites that they refer to for writing their books. Therefore, it is rather easy to edit the books written by the upcoming authors. They do not mind numerous feedbacks and author queries, which an editor who does not have the knowledge of the subject, may raise. The same is the case with the already established authors, as they feel the heat of competition form the upcoming authors. Thus, they are doubly ready to work in accordance with the editor and take care of every query made in their content. However, as an editor, you may have to be cautious of instances in which you may overdo and make unnecessary queries. This may entail a demand from author to replace the editor working on his/ her subject. That will definitely not show any good on you part and damage the reputation of the publishing house. Therefore, you should not raise any query without reconfirming your doubt form some other source, e.g., Internet or the books on the same subject and syllabus published by other publishers.

The Danger of Making a Mess

If you have the knowledge of the subject matter, chances are that a situation may be created in which you may contradict some theory that the author may carry in the book, or you may loose concentration in editing, thinking that there could not be any error, whatsoever, in the content, or may overlook it once you pick up speed of editing the subject that you already know. On the other hand, if you have no knowledge of the subject that you are editing, you will certainly be doubly alert while editing so that you do not commit any fatal mistake, which in turn may earn you the author’s anger.

Therefore, not having the knowledge of the subject matter leaves you with a preconditioned mindset, which helps you in averting any type of error and thus brings good results and better products/ content/ books in the market.


Popular posts from this blog


In the field of essay writing, as a beginner, it is essential to have ample confidence in your abilities. In addition, to sustain this confidence until you acquire good essay writing skills is extremely important. Therefore, to start with, it is advised that you pick up some easy essay topics and gradually start choosing some difficult ones.
Here is a list of 50 essay topics for the beginners. The topics range from very easy, to easy, to difficult ones. It is advised that you start from the very easy topics and gradually move towards the difficult essay topics. The word limit for these topics is 350—450 words. The list of essay topics for beginners is as follows:
My father/mother/brother/sister/grandfather/grandmotherMy petMy schoolMy favorite teacherMy city/town/villageMy new dressMy favorite dish (food item)My first train rideMy countryMy favorite sports activity/gameMy first day at new class/schoolMy best friendMy favorite bookMy favorite hero/heroine/role modelMy favorite festival…

100 Ancient Indian History Multiple Choice Questions - I

The following are 100 multiple choice questions of the ancient Indian history. These could be useful for the aspirants of UPSC and UGC. Readers are encouraged to solve them. To acquire answers of these questions and to submit any remarks or feedback, feel free to contact at Always mention the question paper code (given in bold letters) in any kind of correspondence. 

Question Bank – 1 (Code – 14-02AJ001) Ancient Indian History

1.The famous oriental scholar of Germany, Max Muller, belonged to the school of philologists of a.18 Century b.19 Century c.20 Century d.21 Century 2.Who wrote Ancient India from the Earliest Times to the First Century AD (1914 published)? a.Max Muller b.E.J. Rapson c.Adolf Kaegi d.E.B. Taylor 3.‘Zend’ was the language of a.Indian Aryans b.European Aryans c.Persian Aryans d.Central Asian Aryans 4.Brahmavartta  was the a.Land between river Sarasvati and Drsadvati b.Name of an Aryan king c.Land in ancient Kabul d.A noted prime minister in Mahabharata 5.Ariana…

Inner Voice: Immediate Issues of Life

Everyone has short and long term goals in his/her life. These goals may be to get thin, to earn and save lot of money, to have a beautiful girlfriend or a handsome boyfriend, to own a luxury car, etc.

Among all such mundane goals, there seems no requirement of interference of the inner voice of an individual. However, if you are under the spell of your inner voice, just like me, I advise you to arrange your goals. These can be fundamentally organised into short term goals and long term goals. 

On the basis of such a self-made arrangement, start focusing on your inner voice. Ask common and specialized questions to your inner voice about each of your desires. As I have got, you will also get some answers; some questions may not be answered at this point of time. It is a must-believe situation. Without trusting the inner voice, there is no other choice in such cases. Hence such an arrangement. 

A better way to deal with such a situation is to focus on your immediate, most important, urgent …